Crown Thinning: Letting The Wind Through The Canopy
Crown thinning means selectively removing a proportion of the smaller branches through the crown, spread evenly, so what is left is the same shape and the same size but less dense.
The point is that wind passes through rather than pushing against. A dense crown behaves like a sail; a thinned one lets the gusts spill. On the shallow-rooted trees that the sandy Oak Plains ground under Paris produces, that matters more than it would elsewhere, because the failure mode here is the root plate lifting rather than the trunk breaking.
The limit for crown thinning and canopy reduction is about a quarter of the live crown in any one visit, and less on an older tree. Take more and you have shocked it into throwing out replacement growth, denser than what you removed. That is the mistake we get called to correct most often on trees along the Grand River valley, where the wind exposure tempts people into taking too much at once.
Reduction: Taking Size Off Properly
Crown thinning and canopy reduction are not the same cut. Canopy reduction shortens the limbs, and every cut has to land on a lateral branch large enough to take over as the new end of that limb. Roughly a third the diameter of what came off is the working rule.
That is what separates reduction from topping. Reduction leaves a smaller tree with a natural outline and a live growing point at the end of every cut limb. Topping leaves stubs, and the tree answers with weak regrowth off the wound faces.
A reduction is usually specified as a distance rather than a percentage — "reduce the two lowest limbs by about two metres" — because that is checkable afterwards, and a percentage is not.
Which Kind Of Crown Thinning And Canopy Reduction You Need
If the problem is that the garden underneath gets no light, or the lawn will not grow, that is thinning.
If the problem is that a limb is over the roof, over the drive, or close to a wire, that is reduction on that limb — often just one or two of them, not the whole tree. On the narrow lots through central Paris that is most of the reduction work we do.
If the problem is that a big multi-stemmed silver maple has a union you do not trust, thinning and reduction both help by taking leverage off it, but the real answer may be cabling and bracing or, eventually, removal.
If the problem is that the tree is too big for the garden and always will be, no amount of crown reduction fixes that permanently. It buys years, and it has to be repeated. Sometimes the honest answer is replacing it with something the right size.
What Crown Thinning And Canopy Reduction Will Not Do
Crown thinning and canopy reduction do not make a tree safe. They reduce load, which reduces risk. A tree with a decayed base is not improved by taking weight off the top of it in any way that matters.
They also do not fix a tree that has already been topped. A topped tree's regrowth is attached to the surface of old wounds rather than anchored in sound wood, and no amount of subsequent trimming changes that. What it needs is a long programme of gradual reduction on the regrowth, forever, or removal.